About four minutes into the reception, the bride still outside taking pics with her dad, someone’s cousin is at the buffet for the second time. Chances are that these things have happened at a wedding you’ve been to. And if you work as a wedding caterer, banquet server or wedding bartender, you witness some version of all of these things every single Saturday.
Catering staff are on hand to see the common things guests do at weddings, and they have a lot to say about it. Complaints about common wedding guest faux pas happen behind closed (kitchen) doors. And apparently on Reddit, too. We already covered the questions guests ask that make couples cringe. This is the reception version, from the people holding the trays.
If you’re in the throes of wedding planning, now might be a good time to brush up on how not to be the guest your caterer never wants to see again. Below are the 16 complaints that came up over and over, in the caterers’ own words. (Good thing most of them are preventable with one line on your wedding website or one conversation during your final walkthrough!)
1. Switching From Chicken to Beef Once Dinner Starts
One caterer who had worked “tons of weddings” in the first six months on the job opened a Reddit list with this one, and other catering workers piled in behind: “People don’t seem to realize that getting food catered is not like ordering from a restaurant. If the event is plated and guests get a choice of protein, you can’t just switch protein last minute. The amount of times a guest who chose chicken on the invite asks for beef at the start of service is crazy. Sometimes we have extra, but we receive a count based on RSVPs.”
Translation: The chef makes x number of chicken and x number of beef. They buy the meat accordingly and they plate up dinner accordingly. If one guest asks to switch it’s one thing, as caterers usually have a few extra of both entrées just in case. But if several people at a table change their mind, someone gets the wrong entrée OR a server goes into the kitchen only to be met with the panicked look from the chef who knows there are no more plates of said entrée to be had.
List meal choices on your RSVP card AND your wedding website. Then be sure to send your caterer the final meal count, including who gets what by table number. Our post on RSVP mistakes that drive brides crazy has the full list of what goes wrong with reply cards.
2. Mentioning Your Allergy While They’re Clearing the Salad
The same caterer builds a cushion for the vegetarians: “If we hear that there’s three vegetarian guests, we’ll prep for four or five because someone who has steak always decides last minute that they want a vegetarian plate.” A cushion covers one or two surprise vegetarians. It doesn’t cover this, from another catering worker: “Father of the bride demands a low sodium meal which was NOT ordered and informs us he needs one while we’re clearing the first course.”
The story that made us wince was the same caterer’s alternating-salad wedding: “A couple wanted plated salads, but they wanted the salads to alternate. So salad A would be in seat 1, salad B to seat 2, and so on. Guests could not pick their salad. We found out later that a guest with a nut allergy had to find someone willing to trade salads with them because the salad they randomly got had nuts. We were not informed of this allergy.”
The bottom line for the couples out there is to consider adding a line about allergies on the RSVP portion of the invitations (this is extra painless if you have online RSVPs) and then be sure to share the answers with your caterer by name and by seat when it’s crunch time for meal decisions. And guests, do pass along your allergies when you RSVP, it’s much easier on everyone.
3. Calling the Caterer Yourself to Arrange a Different Meal
One bride in the final stretch of planning found out that a groomsman’s wife had gone around her entirely: “Turns out, they went to our venue site, found the caterers, and “made their own arrangements” so she could have chicken kebabs.” The caterers hadn’t flagged it either. “I reached out to the caterers and they said they hadn’t realized my fiancé and I didn’t know the guest was calling them.”
A chef who says they’ve worked about 4,000 weddings told her this happens more than you’d think:
As a chef with ~4000 weddings worked, this is pretty common. I’ve been contacted many times by a future guest about allergies. I’m not sure if any of them had permission from the bride and groom to reach out to me, but it didn’t cross my mind, nor did I ask.
a wedding chef, on Reddit
The chef added that it was never an extra charge and not to take it personally, while admitting the kitchen feels it: “It’s a pretty stressful situation though, because you’re thinking about it all day to avoid cross contamination etc…” Still, the last thing you want to do is surprise the couple by landing one of their guests’ side arrangements on their catering bill. Ask the couple first, and leave it to them to work it out with the caterers.
4. Taking the Whole Tray of Passed Appetizers

From the six-months-in caterer again: “There’s always one guest who will approach the servers and take all twelve appetizers off their tray. Then we get scolded for not bringing enough.” The same caterer also explained why one guest’s haul matters so much: “We can only bring what’s paid for. Apps are priced by the piece, not by the guest.”
Let’s say the couple paid for 300 passed apps to serve 100 guests, that’s three per guest. The person who inhales twelve apps has eaten through four people’s share, and the servers are going to hear “where did all the appetizers go?” for the rest of cocktail hour.
Talk with your caterer to determine how many bites per guest you’ll be providing, and think about supplementing passed food with something stationary (a cheese board, crudité table, etc.) so there are fewer little appetizer pirates running around the room sniffing out food trays. Our guide to what wedding catering costs around the country has the per-person ranges.
5. Making a Plate Before the Buffet Is Open

One parent of the bride watched it happen at their own daughter’s reception, while the couple was still off taking photos: “We watched the groom’s brother-in-law idly wandering down the buffet table making himself a plate.” Her niece leaned over and said what everyone at the table was thinking: “you don’t touch that food until the bride and groom have been served!”
Another guest still remembers a Christmas wedding they went to as a kid, where their family arrived from the church (the bride’s side had stayed for photos) to find nothing left. “The dinner was a large buffet table…that was completely empty by the time my family and the newly married couple arrived. The groom’s family had completely decimated the buffet table.” Years later their mom explained what happened: “the groom’s family didn’t think to wait for everyone else to arrive before digging in”
This is less a problem for guests to fix, and more for the couple and caterer. The buffet should not be opened until the couple makes an appearance in the room. Have the couple go first, followed by guests. Ideally the DJ or coordinator will herd the hungry masses table by table (recruit an organized friend or family member if need be!) so there’s not a fifty-person mosh pit of hungry people barreling toward the buffet at once. Our post on what wedding coordinators fix before the ceremony covers that job, too.
6. Going Back for Seconds Before Every Table Has Been Called
One guest put it plainly: “in many weddings with buffets I’ve seen people going back for a second plate before all the tables were called.” That was in a thread about a buffet that ran out before a whole table could eat. A bride in the same thread had added a couple thousand dollars to her catering budget specifically so the food wouldn’t run out, and it still did:
They ran out of food before we finished taking our pictures. My entire wedding party didn’t get food bc apparently some guests were so rude they actually shoved staff out of the way to serve themselves when the staff tried to shut the line down to fix plates for the wedding party.
a bride, on Reddit
“my cousin mentioned she saw some people she didn’t know getting fourths while people were waiting to get their first plates.” And the table that gets called last gets this, from another guest: “Protein was all gone by the time our table of 10 was called up. Some soggy lettuce at the bottom of the salad and very limp looking veggies.”
Ask your caterer about having the proteins manned and portioned instead of self-serve. With buffets, if your guest count is over 100, ask if it’s possible to have two buffet lines, and have the DJ make an announcement about seconds after all the guests have been served.
7. Asking for Seconds at a Plated Dinner
Plated dinners are counted per seat, which one guest treated as a loophole:
A couple weeks ago I was bartending a wedding and a guest told a caterer he wanted seconds of a plated dinner. When the caterer said that the dinner was plated, not buffet, and the couple paid per seat he literally got up and went and sat at an empty chair and said “well this seat is empty!”. They did make him another plate so one of the vendors didn’t eat that night.
a bartender who works weddings, on Reddit
That extra plate was somebody’s dinner, and at a lot of weddings the somebody is the photographer who has been on her feet since 10 a.m. In my Smart Wedding Planner I tell couples to sort this out early: “You will need to arrange this with your venue/caterer, and ask them what type of vendor meals they serve (ideally a version of what your guests are eating).” Order a few extra plates on top of the vendor meals if your budget allows, because a kitchen with two spare entrées handles the seconds guy without anyone going hungry.
8. Switching Seats Halfway Through Dinner

A server who worked a lot of weddings put this near the top of their list: “One thing that really annoyed me was when people swapped seats midway through the meal. We took the order we know what seat is eating what. We don’t want to be running around trying to find you out of 200 guests.”
It gets worse when the map itself is wrong. One catering worker described a wedding where the coordinator moved the tables after the paperwork was printed: “the wedding coordinator rearranged the tables so all the tables, numbers, and guests were off sync with the paperwork we had. When it came to serve dinner, we were all confused on where to go and who to serve. Tables were getting half served and mixed meals.”
Remember to use those place cards! They may seem extra or unnecessary to guests, but if you’re a server, they’re super helpful. Some couples use different colored dots or even tiny food icons on the cards to indicate each guest’s entrée order. If you’re the couple, our post on seating mistakes that cause drama will save your caterer a headache.
9. Fingers in the Dipping Sauce (and Forks in Someone Else’s Dinner)
Same catering worker, same wedding. One guest had already sent her filet back twice, then “that guest, who we found out was the bride’s aunt, decided to eat off of the maid of honor’s dinner plate while she was off dancing.” Then the late-night pretzel station went out: “the aunt comes up to the station with her daughter and starts to put the dipping sauces straight onto plates. Problem was we didn’t even put out spoons. They were using their fingers and hands to put the sauces onto the plates.” Three coworkers saw it. “We had no choice but to throw all those sauces away.”
The couple, to their credit, had both ladies escorted out. At the same wedding, “a different guest decided to go behind the DJ booth and change the entire wedding playlist. The DJ saw and yelled so loud at the guest it was heard over the music.” We’re sharing this one because every catering worker in the thread had a cousin-with-the-sauces story of their own. If there’s no spoon, the food isn’t ready. If the plate isn’t yours, neither is the dinner on it.
10. Drinking Like the Open Bar Is a Contest
A former caterer summed up the whole category in one line: “I used to cater weddings in NE PA (USA). What was unacceptable before the open bar became acceptable after.” A bartender who works weddings independently described a crowd that drank through the entire order: “Early 20 something group drinking like they will be hit by a bus, and we ran out of liquor. I had sent the bride a shopping list of quantities to buy, and they ignored.”
Self-serve bars are where it gets dangerous. A server helping a friend staff an outdoor wedding watched guests doctor the premade cocktails: “Some people were taking the premade cocktail and adding more liquor to them. One guy was getting noticeably wasted by doing this.” At the end of the night the venue had a golf cart to shuttle people to the far parking lot. “This drunk guy gets in it and smashes it into the party bus. Cops show up, and he gets a DUI.”
Have a bartender even if you just plan on beer and wine, and don’t leave liquor out unattended. There’s also this nifty wedding alcohol calculator if you want to find out how much liquor you’ll need based on your number of guests.
11. Arguing With the Bartender Who Cut You Off

A bartender who worked a wedding paid for by a soda executive (the venue had to pull every competing can off the bar) described the guest who turned the bar into a hazard: “Another wasted guy kept breaking glasses and blocking access to the bar. Bride attempted to order shots for this man, and was very upset when I politely explained that I wasn’t comfortable serving him more liquor when he couldn’t stand up but I’d get him a coffee or soft drink.”
Another server explained the gentle version of a cut-off, which you have probably received without knowing it: “I’ve found that when cutting people off it’s a bad idea to flat out tell them it’s because they are drunk, especially if there are other people around. It embarrassed them and makes them more belligerent.” So they sidestep the request instead. “Can I get a drink?” “How about some coffee instead?” If a bartender offers you coffee at a wedding, that IS the cut-off. Take the coffee, thank them, and go dance.
12. Complaining About the Cash Bar (or Ordering a 13-Ingredient Cocktail)
A banquet bartender who worked a lot of weddings had two bar peeves that go together. The first: “Guests who complain of a cash bar or other cost-saving elements at a wedding. Sorry the bride and groom didn’t go all out to completely fund a hedonistic evening for you.” The second: “People who want crazy mixed cocktails with 13 ingredients at a banquet bar. You’re at a wedding, not a hipster speakeasy. Get a gin and tonic or jack and coke like everyone else, or drink the wine.”
Most couples who limit the bar are reacting to the per-person math. In my Smart Wedding Planner I explain that “Most beverage catering is priced using a per person package rate (IE: $40/pp for 4 hours of open bar) or consumption.” Every hour the bar stays open is a per-person charge, and that’s how a beer-and-wine bar or a limited bar ends up on the table. (Our post on bartender secrets for saving on your open bar walks through the numbers.) And the parent of the bride from the buffet story had one more: at their other daughter’s wedding, “the groom’s cousins all stampeded into the dining area and collected as many drink tickets as they could grab before the venue staff managed to stop them.”
13. Bringing People Who Never RSVP’d
One commenter whose mom caters on the side told the story of a backyard wedding booked for 50 guests. Her mom brought enough for 75, because, as she put it, people tend to bring uninvited guests. Then “probably 150 people were cramming into this backyard for this wedding.” “And just as soon as they start showing up they beeline for the food. One guest asks for both entrées and the bride’s mom says it’s okay so she gives it to them, and of course then EVERYONE starts asking for both, as well as multiple sides, salads, etc.”
Her mom sent someone to a local restaurant for more food and still got a screaming phone call at 3 a.m. from the father of the bride, who said she’d ruined the wedding by not providing enough. “My mom very politely but firmly explained they paid for 50 people, my mom brought enough for 75”. This is what the RSVP deadline is for, and it’s why your caterer’s final-count cutoff isn’t negotiable. One venue and catering worker, answering a bride who wanted to fudge her number: “The reason for the 15 day cut off is rentals and food orders. Those are placed around 15-10 days out.” “Their contract likely says they aren’t responsible for accommodating anything past your official count given 2 weeks out. So your guests would also probably go hungry or without chairs etc”
In my Smart Wedding Planner I do tell couples to pad the rentals: “While your caterer will provide you with an exact number, plan on ordering 10% more table settings and chairs for guests than you need.” That covers a cousin who shows up. It doesn’t cover a hundred extra humans. Our plus-one etiquette guide has the wording for the invitation and the website.
14. Asking to Box Up the Leftovers (in Containers You Brought From Home)
One guest watched three friends of the bride tell a young staffer (the supervisor was in the back) that the bride had given them permission to “grab some food.” “These three women filled multiple to go plates each of shrimp, lamb, etc. by the time the food person came back out, about half the buffet was gone and what was left had been stirred/mushed around and looked awful. The friends didn’t even stay for the reception and had even taken a third of the groom’s cake and the top two tiers off the wedding cake.”
Caterers aren’t hoarding your leftovers, by the way. One caterer who does street-food weddings: “we have zero desire to take any food away with us. You ordered it, you paid for it so it’s yours.” The same caterer said “if we have extra then we are plying guests with it and persuading the early-to-leave guests to take some home like we’re your Jewish Granny!” The catch is food safety. A commenter whose friend runs a large catering company described an outdoor buffet in 98-degree heat where “By the time service was done with dinner, the food had been out in the sun for over four hours. Even with everything kept to hot or cold standards, the food would not have been safe to be packaged and kept afterward.” “The bride had a full melt down and insisted that catering could have just wrapped it all up for her to take home.”
Etiquette expert Nick Leighton, asked by Business Insider about guests taking food home, put it this way: “The hosts want you to have a nice time, but they probably don’t want to cater all your meals for the week.” If you’re the couple and you want the leftovers, ask the caterer at the walkthrough what’s safe to pack and who will pack it. If you’re a guest, wait to be offered, and leave the Tupperware at home.
15. Letting the Kids Loose on the Self-Serve Stations
We love kids at weddings (a flower girl on the dance floor at 10 p.m. is the best part of some receptions). A sundae bar, on the other hand, isn’t childcare. From the six-months-in caterer: “our coordinator had to take one of the self-serve toppings spoons from a child’s mouth” One commenter in the thread said what the staff can’t say to a parent’s face: “If you bring your child to a wedding reception, you are responsible for watching them and that includes during cocktail hour and dinner.”
If your wedding is an adults-only affair, let guests know ahead of time (possibly right on your website), and if children are welcome, spell out what you have planned for them. Our post on how to have an adults-only wedding has the gentle wording.
16. Toasts That Push Dinner Back an Hour
Caterers plan dinner to the minute, and the one thing they can’t control is the microphone. A catering worker who posted after a 200-guest wedding where their entire front-of-house staff called in said being behind wasn’t their fault: “Speeches took forever, there were like six “first dances”. It was not a fun event for us.” Another catering worker in the thread: “we strongly discourage couples from doing speeches between courses, as it throws off the timing for everything.”
A DJ who did a friend’s wedding as a gift watched the whole night slide: “The ceremony started a half hour late, so already they’re cutting into the cocktail/picture time before even starting. They took 45 minutes past the cocktail time for photos.” “Everything just slid after that. Speeches, extra 30 minutes.” And the street-food caterer from the leftovers story: “I’ve never catered a wedding that ran to time. Not one.” Meanwhile the food sits. The commenter whose friend caters large weddings described the 98-degree buffet again: “The wedding party was over an hour late to the reception, and my friend wasn’t allowed to serve early.”
Limit the toasts during dinner to only two or three people and time limit their comments. Save the more informal toasts and surprises for the rehearsal dinner. Our post on how long a wedding reception should be walks through the timeline.
Do You Tip the Catering Staff at a Wedding?
After reading all of this you may want to hand the servers cash on your way out, and sometimes that’s the right call. In my Smart Wedding Planner I remind couples that “Gratuity is often included for catering, transportation, and even musicians.” and that “Most catering contracts include gratuity in the final bill, so you wouldn’t have to do anything additional unless you felt certain staff or managers did an amazing job.” Check your contract first. If the service charge is already 20 percent, you’re covered, and if a server handled your cousin and the dipping sauces with a straight face, a cash thank-you at the end of the night is a lovely thing to do.
If you’re a guest at a catered wedding: RSVP early and choose your dinner option if applicable, wait for your table to be called before lining up for dinner, leave a good tip for the bartender(s), and let the catering staff pack up the leftovers (do not volunteer!). For the flip side, we also collected the biggest complaints guests have about weddings.
Some links in this post may be affiliate links, which means we may earn a small commission if you make a purchase through them. Thank you for your support!


I never put the plates on the buffet table until we are ready to start. That solves the early diner problem. I’ve had guests ask if they could have their food before everyone else because they needed to leave. I just say “Sorry, dinner is not ready yet.”