Vintage engagement rings have a way of standing out, not just because of their timeless designs but because they tell a story. These rings go beyond the standard diamond solitaire, bringing in rich colors, intricate details, and a touch of old-world craftsmanship. Whether it’s the dramatic shift of an alexandrite, the regal elegance of a sapphire, or the warm glow of a citrine, each gemstone adds personality to the setting. Some styles embrace delicate floral-inspired details, while others lean into bold Art Deco lines or moody, unconventional elements. If you’re drawn to rings with history and character, there’s no shortage of stunning options to consider.
Alexandrite Vintage Engagement Ring
There’s something undeniably intriguing about an alexandrite engagement ring. One moment, it flashes deep teal; the next, it shifts to a moody purplish hue. This pear-shaped stunner from Staghead Designs wraps the color-changing gemstone in a delicate diamond halo, balancing elegance with just the right amount of drama. The intricately detailed band adds to its vintage appeal, making this a solid choice for anyone who loves a ring with personality.
Amethyst Vintage Engagement Ring
Amethyst may not be the first gemstone that comes to mind for an engagement ring, but this piece from Wolf & Badger makes a compelling case. Set in warm gold, the oval-cut purple stone is surrounded by a cluster of small diamonds in a design that feels like a nod to Victorian jewelry. The floral-inspired setting adds a delicate touch, but make no mistake—this ring is anything but dainty. If you want a vintage ring that stands out without veering into over-the-top territory, this might be the one.
Aquamarine Vintage Engagement Ring
If mermaids wore engagement rings, they’d probably choose something like this. The Bella Aquamarine Ring from Capucinne features a soft blue gemstone cradled in an ornate rose gold band, complete with a matching diamond-studded contour ring. The vintage-inspired filigree detailing adds old-world charm, while the cool tones of aquamarine keep it feeling fresh. This is one of those rings that’s effortlessly romantic without trying too hard.
Black Diamond Vintage Engagement Ring
Black diamonds have an undeniable edge, and this dramatic ring from 1st Dibs fully embraces it. The bold marquise-cut black diamond sits in a sculpted yellow gold setting, accented by a shimmering halo. This isn’t your standard vintage engagement ring—it’s moody, unconventional, and perfect for someone who isn’t afraid to break tradition.
Citrine Vintage Engagement Ring
Citrine’s golden-orange glow brings warmth to any piece of jewelry, and this ring from Local Eclectic makes full use of that charm. The emerald-cut citrine stone takes center stage, framed by delicate diamond accents for an Art Deco-inspired look. The warm hues of the gemstone and gold band give it a distinctly vintage feel, making it a great pick for anyone who wants a ring with a bit of 1920s flair.
Diamond Vintage Engagement Ring
Sometimes, classic is best. The Lola Ring from Ken & Dana Design features a marquise-cut diamond in a delicately engraved gold band, blending vintage and timeless elements. The side diamonds add just the right amount of sparkle without overwhelming the design. If you love old-world craftsmanship but still want something refined enough for everyday wear, this ring delivers.
Emerald Vintage Engagement Ring
For those who love a regal touch, this Verdeline Green Emerald Ring from Rustic & Main is an instant favorite. The deep green marquise-cut emerald is the centerpiece, surrounded by a delicate diamond halo and baguette side stones. The yellow gold band ties it all together with a warmth that enhances the rich color of the emerald. It’s vintage-inspired, but with a fresh, modern take.
Garnet Vintage Engagement Ring
Deep red garnets have been used in jewelry for centuries, and this ring from Rosec Jewels keeps that tradition alive. The octagon-cut garnet is wrapped in a diamond-studded floral halo, giving it an antique feel. The ornate gold band leans into the vintage aesthetic, making this ring a strong choice for anyone who loves old-school romance with a touch of drama.
Moissanite Vintage Engagement Ring
If you’re after sparkle, moissanite is a solid alternative to traditional diamonds. The Payson Ring from Olive Ave Jewelry takes that brilliance and pairs it with an ornate vintage setting. The oval-cut moissanite stone sits in an intricate gold frame, adorned with delicate filigree details and small diamond accents. It’s the kind of ring that feels straight out of an old-world fairy tale—minus the outdated price tag.
Morganite Vintage Engagement Ring
Morganite has a softness that makes it perfect for vintage-style rings, and Rustic & Main plays into that beautifully. The oval-cut peach morganite is set in a minimalist gold band, letting the warm tones shine. It’s simple but elegant, with just enough vintage charm to make it feel special without going overboard. If you like subtle romance over flashy designs, this one is worth considering.
Pearl Vintage Engagement Ring
Pearls aren’t the usual pick for engagement rings, but this three-stone pearl and diamond ring from Andria Barboné proves they deserve a spot in the lineup. The center diamond is flanked by two creamy pearls, all set in warm yellow gold for a vintage look that leans toward classic elegance. It has an old-world charm that feels timeless rather than trendy, making it perfect for those who appreciate understated beauty.
Peridot Vintage Engagement Ring
For an engagement ring that feels a little unexpected, this rutile peridot ring from Eden Garden Jewelry is a conversation starter. The green gemstone has delicate golden threads running through it, giving it an almost ethereal quality. The setting leans into the vintage aesthetic with sculpted gold details, while the pear-cut stone keeps things fresh. If you’re into nature-inspired jewelry with a touch of antique charm, this one checks all the boxes.
Rose Quartz Vintage Engagement Ring
Rose quartz is often associated with love, so it makes sense as a gemstone choice for an engagement ring. The 14K gold rose quartz ring from Jaded Design NYC takes this symbolism and runs with it, featuring a soft pink center stone wrapped in a delicate diamond halo. The vintage-style rose gold band enhances the romance factor without going too ornate. It’s an ideal ring for someone who loves soft, feminine designs but doesn’t want anything too flashy.
Ruby Vintage Engagement Ring
Nothing says vintage glamour like a deep red ruby surrounded by diamonds. This 2-carat oval ruby halo ring from Bellawie is straight out of an old Hollywood movie, with its dramatic red gemstone and sparkling halo. The rose gold setting gives it a warm, romantic feel, while the diamond-studded band adds extra brilliance. If you want an engagement ring that looks bold and regal, this one is hard to ignore.
Sapphire Vintage Engagement Ring
Sapphire engagement rings have long been associated with royalty (looking at you, Princess Diana), and this Sanctum Ring from Common Ground Jewelry embraces that legacy. The deep blue sapphire is set in yellow gold with diamond accents, creating a striking contrast that feels both elegant and timeless. The geometric cut of the stone gives it a unique edge, making it perfect for anyone who wants a vintage engagement ring with a bit of an art deco twist.
A vintage engagement ring isn’t just a piece of jewelry—it’s a symbol of love with a story to tell. Whether you’re drawn to the rich hues of a sapphire, the bold elegance of a black diamond, or the delicate charm of a pearl, these rings bring timeless beauty to modern romance. No matter your style, a vintage-inspired design ensures your ring will be as unique and unforgettable as your love story.
Some links in this post may be affiliate links, which means we may earn a small commission if you make a purchase through them. Thank you for your support!
